4 Comments
User's avatar
Aditya Padmanaba's avatar

Just last week, a big "Sustainability Forum" had Hashim as a main speaker. This is not too far from having Human Rights conference with Netanyahu doing the keynote

Raisa Rifat's avatar

I'm too disillusioned with today's leaders that "let leaders get to work" makes me think "yeah, right, haha." But I agree.

I feel like, at best, a background force behind many of these conferences is a response based on helplessness. Like we're facing a hyperproblem that might force us to abandon so much of our current system, but change is scary! So we're having talks about it uwu. At worst, that background force is a mix of inertia and peacocking.

Adhiwidyawisesa's avatar

I think this is a visible example of a bigger, underrated problem of cost effectiveness and opportunity costs.

What's mentioned in the article, but not explicitly framed this way, is that the benefit of these conferences may no longer justifies the costs (money, time, effort, and emissions). Perhaps the earliest conferences did, but it's clear to see that the costs have ballooned faster than the benefits.

I think it's a problem not just in the climate sector, but in any social-impact programs, may it be from governments or nonprofits alike.

I understand that even making a positive causal difference is difficult on its own, and that not every activity should be evaluated based on its cost effectiveness; but for something of this magnitude, I figure someone ought to haha

Climate leaders could make better use of their time yes, but also imagine what the world could have achieved with all the money, effort, and attention spent on these conferences instead.

Rabindra's avatar

I do think about this too.

I’ve attended some of the local events as a participant, and I started cutting back. There’s always something new, of course, but the difference from year to year is small. The content is similar from one event to the next, and so are many of the speakers. I still learn a thing or two and love running into friends, but I’ve become much more selective about which events are worth my time.

That’s why your point about opportunity cost feels accurate. If an event is only mildly useful for someone like me, what is it costing the officials and leaders whose time is better spent implementing the very things being discussed? That said, I’m grateful when they do take the time to share their experience and knowledge.

I agree that there should be fewer convenings. But I’m also wondering whether these events could be made accountable the way a corporate meeting is (gosh, I think I’ve already fallen into the trap of “corporatification” in a sense). At the end of each one, there would be action items, each with a PIC, a deadline, and a target (should be ambitious), and the following year’s event would open by reviewing progress on them. New initiatives also should be measured against the target(s). I’m not sure how to implement that, but someone has to own the follow-up. Without an owner, action items just become another ritual.

This is also what should set sustainability events apart from a marketing seminar or tech forum, which mostly exist to share the latest industry updates. Sustainability has issues that need to be tracked together year after year, so the event should be more than “talk, meet, see you next year.”